Posted by: Kylene Beers | 20th Aug, 2012

Why I Hated Meredith’s First Grade Teacher: An Open Letter to America’s Teachers

When my first born headed off to first grade, 21 years ago, she held my hand as we walked down the hallway of Will Rogers Elementary School in the Houston Independent School District. We walked into Ms. Miner’s room and Meredith’s steps grew more hesitant. This wasn’t the University of Houston Child Care Center, the place she had gone for years while I was a doctoral student at UH. This place looked different – bigger, more official. There were big-kid desks pushed together in clusters. And though there were centers, they were not the dress-up center or the cooking center or nap center or water play center of the Child Care Center.

The room was filled with children she did not yet know, with books she had not yet read, with a math center that had lost-teeth and birthday charts, and with a big poster by the door labeled, “Our Classroom Rules” that was still blank. “I don’t want to stay,” she said.  I didn’t want her to, either. I wanted her still with me, only me. I didn’t want to give up those first six years of childhood just yet, those years when her world mostly revolved around her parents and new baby brother and a silly dog with big ears and afternoons spent in our local library reading book after book after book or playing in our neighborhood park, sometimes just sitting on the grass, watching the ants march by. With every ounce of courage, I said, “Oh, you will love first grade. It was my favorite year in school. I loved my first grade teacher, Mrs. Allen, and I bet you are going to love Ms. Miner, too.” Meredith looked doubtful and so very small. And then Ms. Miner, long blond hair pulled back into a ponytail, saw us, came over, and bent down to Meredith’s level.  A first year teacher – the one I had told the principal that if he was willing to listen to requests I wanted – Ms. Miner was full of energy and excitement. She loved books, wanted to be a great teacher, and had obviously spent weeks making her room look inviting to these 22 six-year-olds.

“Oh, you’re Meredith! I recognized you from your picture! Come here and let me introduce you to some others. And let me show you all around the room. And, hey, you brought Corduroy as your favorite book and that’s one of my favorite books, too!”

And then, somehow, without me even realizing, Meredith’s small hand moved from mine to Ms. Miner’s and she was gone. She was swallowed up by the sheer joy this other woman brought into her classroom, into learning, and into my child’s life. “I guess I’ll be going now,” I said to Meredith who was busy putting school supplies away in her desk. “So, I’ll be just around the corner at our house,” I said blinking hard to keep away the tears.” I think she nodded. Perhaps she even paused to wave. My feet couldn’t move and Ms. Miner gently helped me and a few other moms out of the classroom. “She’s really shy,” I said to Ms. Miner just as Meredith sped by holding a new friend’s hand showing her “all these hooks where we can hang our backpacks.”

Meredith was breathless with excitement at the end of that day – every day – and by the end of the first week, our family had a new member: Ms. Miner. Each afternoon and for long into the evening, I had to listen to “Ms. Miner said . . .” and “Ms. Miner thinks . . .” and “Ms. Miner showed us . . .” and “Ms. Miner suggested . . .” and when I slipped and said, “Oh damn” at dinner burned in the oven, I was reminded that “Mom, Ms. Miner would never say . . .  .”  Right, I smiled through gritted teeth.  ”Ms. Miner says that manners are important,” Meredith said as she explained why we must always put our napkins in our laps, something that I swear I had mentioned a million times.

For the entire year I watched my child fall in love with school, with learning, with figuring out, and most importantly, with her first grade teacher, Ms. Miner. Meredith, who had once hated ponytails, now only wanted to wear ponytails. And blue skirts, “just like Ms. Miner’s.” “And Mom, my name starts with an M and Ms. Miner starts with an M. Isn’t that great!! We match!” Yes, Meredith, just great. Really great. Oh damn.

Though I had been a teacher for years before having Meredith, before sending her off to first grade, I had never truly understood the power of a teacher in a child’s life. We give our most precious and priceless to you – dear teachers – each year, knowing you will teach them, but also hoping you will care for them, help them discover how very much they matter, watching over them, and being there when they have been hurt by the ones who won’t let them sit at the “popular” table – and then you do just that and they fall in love with you. It shows up in different ways, as they grow older. But it’s still there, this deep affection and respect. And, certainly, it’s harder to forge those bonds when there are 150 students instead of 22, when the day is fragmented into 45 minute segments, when education seems to be more about the test than the child. But I promise, underneath that bravado of the seventh grader or swagger of the tenth grader you will find that small first grader who wonders, “Will my teacher like me?” And when that child – that teen – knows that you believe he or she matters, then that student will do most anything for you.

To this day, Meredith remembers you, Ms. Miner, and to this day, I so hated how much she loved you that year. And, simultaneously, I am so grateful that she did.

And so, teachers, across this country during the next two weeks, most of you will be opening your classroom doors in a first-day welcoming for your students.  As a teacher I am proud to stand beside you in all that you do. But as a parent, well, as a parent I stand in awe of all that you do.  And to Ms. Miner, thank you.

Responses

Love this post, Our youngest son fell in love with his Kindergarten teacher. At his 1st parent teacher conference Mrs. Isaac asked me, “What does Alex say about me?” I told her he tells me every day that you love what he can create with blocks & that he is your favorite. Still makes me teary to think of her! She was amazing, every child was her favorite child.

This was wonderful! My daughter had her kindergarten teacher affect her the same way! Then was lucky enough to have her again for grade 3! My daughter now in her fourth year of University still is thrilled when we run into Ms fiddler!

As teachers we do make a difference!

I love that he saw himself as her favorite! I suspect that Mrs. Isaac knew how to make each child feel that way!

All the new standards in the world, common or otherwise, won’t make a difference if the teacher in the room doesn’t understand what a difference she or he can make in each child’s life.

What an incredibly important post for not only first grade teachers but also for high school teachers. You made me cry! Thank you so much for writing such a beautiful tribute and challenge to teachers to be the one our children adore and admire, regardless of their grade.

My daughter has been so blessed with teachers who love her like their own. Her eyes twinkle when she speaks of these amazing women. As a teacher, I have often been told I am a relationship teacher, and now seeing how this allows my cautious daughter to be a risk taker is amazing. My son is just entering first grade and I hope he finds the same loving, accepting teachers my daughter has been blessed with in school. I see the effects of students who didn’t bond with their teachers in elementary school in the courses I teach. Thank you for writing this, I hope all teachers read about the importance of loving them all.

Wow. I am a high school teacher. I have a daughter entering first grade, and she’s already in love with her teacher (a new teacher) and wishes school already started. I am happy for my daughter who was so nervous until she met her teacher last week. I am grateful for this teacher for making my daughter feel so welcomed even before school started. And thanks to you for perfectly articulating how it feels to let go of my little girl’s hand and place it in someone else’s. Beautiful post.

Every teacher will be inspired by this moving, heartfelt post. Every teacher will also be trembling a little at the eloquent and graphic reminder of the awesome potential of their influence. OK, let’s develop the pedagogy, promote and manage the targets, refine the tests, etc. – but never ever let us forget that we must connect with individual children and their parents with bedrock empathy.

Kylene-
Thank you! As I reflect on those who have impacted my life most, I find that teachers always rank highest. I’ve always been on the enchanted side of admiring student. Now, as a male teacher, I only hope that I can do the work that so many amazing women have done in lower school education. Thanks for the inspiration!
Jay
(Boothbay Lit Retreat Class of 2012)

Jay–Thank you for first being a part of Boothbay Lit Retreat! Always my favorite part of summer! Second, thank you for all you will do to be “Ms. Miner” to your students. It’s all about showing each student he or she matters. That’s it. When students know they matter, then suddenly all we ask them to do matters more to them.

Love this. Made me cry. I’m a 7th, 8th, and 10th grade teacher who needs to remember that these students (including both of my daughters who will be my students this year) were once those 1st graders…and, by the way, my 10th grade daughter’s favorite stuffed toy was Corduroy too.

This was great. With your permission, I would love to share this with my coworkers on our first day of school.

What a beautiful post. I am a teacher, but not a parent. Thanks for this great reminder of just what an amazing responsibility teaching is. I am often humbled when I think about all the parents who entrust their children to me for a school year. What a blessing to be able to partner with parents in teaching the next generation. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

Thank you so much for reminding me that , although teaching the standards and testing is important, we are there to make an impact on these children and they are the most important. I can’t wait to go in tomorrow and give them all another high five!!

*sniffle* Lovely, thank you.

What an amazing year you’ll have, being both Mom and Teacher. Some ups, some downs, I suspect, but mostly a year of memories.

Of course you may! I appreciate you asking…

I love this post. I’ve been thinking about those class lists sitting in my inbox all week. I can’t wait to meet my students after Labor Day.

You are our teacher, you know. We who read your books and follow you around at conferences look to your passion and energy as a light to follow. Thank you, Kylene.

I am about to begin my 27th year as a first grade teacher, and this post was truly inspirational. I would also like the chance to share it with my colleagues on opening day if you would be so gracious.
I remember, in my early years of teaching, a parent telling me that her daughter loved me so much and talked about me so much that she was really tired of hearing my name. I responded, “Well, she talks about her Mom all the time at school, so you need to know that she loves you and thinks about you while she’s here.”
It wasn’t until I had children of my own and sent them off to the same school where I teach, that I realized what she meant. They had great, caring teachers who were my colleagues, but I too grew tired of hearing their names at home.
Thank you for such an eloquent post!

Absolutely share it!

This letter to teachers brings tears to my eyes! Thank you Kylene Beers!!!

Thank you! I “stole” this from Franki and have passed it on. It’s spreading through teachers and friends everywhere! It was beautiful!

Thank you for this.

My older sister Dawn worked in our school district with Autistic children on a one-to-one basis. She got her teaching degree later in life, and we were so proud of her.

She loved it, and her students opened up with her help. She was amazing.

Sadly Dawn never knew how much she touched their lives. She took her own life on 9/1/10.

I still have people come up to me and say they loved her. Students, parents, kids who had her as a lunch aide – they all loved her.

Thank you for letting teachers know how important they are.

Mrs. Beers-
I took a post-graduate class from you years ago at UH. It was by far one of my favorite classes–I thought you were brilliant:) After teaching English for many years, I am now Mom to 3 boys–who I homeschool. My boys may not have this typical experience with their teacher, but I hope that years from now they will appreciate all the hard work I put in…just like Ms. Miner! Loved the article!

This was a truly inspirational article to read, which grabbed my attention due to the title. I thought to myself, “oh no, not an article bashing teachers”, which this was the complete opposite.

I too, am a teacher and with all the changes happening in education over the years I have to constantly remind myself why I went into this profession…..the children. I am honored that each and every year my parents, throughout the years, trust me with their children. My mantra I always keep in the back of my mind is, “this is someones child”. Also being a mother of 2, it is nice to see the reality of the shoe on the other foot, so to speak. I want nothing but the absolute BEST in a teacher for my children, so why wouldn’t I do that best in my own classroom.

My daughter goes off to kindergarten in a couple weeks and is thrilled about going and her new teacher. She has never met her, but I have raved about her, therefore she already loves her and I think that is big too.

Thank you for sharing this wonderful article and I am also going to share it with my co-workers in our opening days. :)

What a gorgeous post. It instantly took me back to my daughter’s earliest years in school. Those memories feel as though they are in a distant past so it was wonderful to think about them again!

Love this. Reposted on my FB business page…for Moms.

I’m a 70 yr old Grandpa & still love Mrs Burns (1st Grade), Mrs Yauk (2nd), Mrs Hopper (3rd), etc. etc. etc. I’m not “in love with them”, but love how they made me feel about myself & other people. I cannot recall the specifics of what they taught me, only that I gained a positive self-image & confidence to be myself without reservations.

Mrs Beers, You sound like that kind of teacher. I bet your students still love you too.

Wow – such powerful words! Thank you! May I share with my principal?

Thank you for your post – this is beautiful! I’m going into my 7th year of teaching and going back to Grade 1 this September. This is such a great reminder of the need to make every individual in my class matter and to show them that they’re special. I always want to be the “Ms Miner” for my students.

Anyone who works with autistic children is a very special person, and if your sister knew how to help these very special kids open up, in any way, then she herself was special. I’m so sorry you lost your sister, but I love that you see what she brought to the world. I’m going to hope, that from time to time, she saw that, too.

Thanks so much for sharing this important part of your life.

I am about to send my very shy daughter and her twin brother to full day kindergarten. I hope they get a Ms. Miner. Thank you for this post that came at just the right time.

This made me smile and cry!!!! Cheers to a new school year!

Thanks from a first grade teacher

Fabulous post! Sure puts it all into perspective :-)
Going to send it along to my fellow OCPS colleagues. Hope we will be seeing more of you and Dr. Probst this year!

Beautiful sentiments. We, too, have seen the value in teachers, as our son (now starting 4th grade) has navigated through elementary school. I was in awe back when I did my directed teaching and decided I did not have what it takes, and I’m even moreso now.
Mark´s last [type] ..Personal Blogs Have Become Ghost Towns

(: What a beautiful story!

Oh my God. Oh. My. God. As a high school English teacher lamenting the end of the shortest summer break of her life, I have to tell you — I needed this. I needed this so badly, I might find out where you live and give you a great, big, sloppy hug and kiss myself. Thank you. Thank you so much for reminding me the import of my job. I haven’t forgotten. Lord knows, I’ve NEVER forgotten, but in these days of teacher bashing and standardized test taking, sometimes, I need a little booster, a little motivation to remind me why I REALLY do this job. Why I REALLY live for this job.
Laura@Catharsis´s last [type] ..Excuse Me…My Hillbilly is Showing

I love this piece. Luckily our daughter’s kindergarten teacher was amazing but her first grade teacher wasn’t.
My daughter had lesbians moms and her teacher was homophobic. We felt it, our daughter was torn, she wanted to love her teacher but her teacher didn’t like her. There was nothing tangible to go on. We fought to get her moved from that class but to no avail. This was at a progressive school too.
Later when my daughter was 9 we were talking about “haters” our family’s term for homophobes when Zoe had a epiphany, “Mrs. G—” was a hater!” Her first real life example.
So blessed are the wonderful teachers and we have been blessed, but there is special place in hell for the mean ones.

Kyleen … how beautifully written … and it makes me feel renewed again as I prepare to work with college students who sometimes make me wonder if what I do matters anymore … I never questioned it when I taught those little ones, it was in their eyes everyday.

Thanks again … you are an amazing educator … I got to hear you speak at Seward’s Plum Creek Literacy Festival, and at CCIRA last February … one of my “she roes”

Wow!!! This is the best teacher story I have read in a while. Reading this is exactly why I continue to teach. Thanks so much for sharing. I bet Ms. Miner is smiling from ear to ear. I wish we heard more positive stories about the impact and power of teachers instead of the doom and gloom that is currently overpowering our media.

Thank you so much for sharing this. I am a Special Education Teacher, in my 6th year. My first 5 years were spent as a “behavior” teacher. I will be a resource and inclusion teacher this school year. I have had some very long nights the past several days worrying about how I am going to make sure that my students do not feel as though I have left them behind, even though I am still in the same building with them and will see them on a daily basis. This helped me to remember that they already know how special they are to me and that I will be there every morning as they get off the bus with a smile, a hug (if they want one) and a reminder, that every day is a new day!!!

[...] (from Kylene Beers in an open letter to America’s teachers) [...]

Thank you Kylene for this relatable story and tribute to Miss Minor and Teachers. We have a First Grader Arden and his Muse and Favorite Teacher also his Kindergarten Teacher is Mrs. Williams. We like him so Love her. We are all blessed to have this Country with great caring educators.
Thanks For Sharing,
Michael and Cameron Simpson
Parents of Arden and Aaron

I love this post!!! I am a recent college grad eager to have my own classroom someday! It is nice to hear a parent’s perspective of the positive impact a teacher can have on his/her students. :) :):)

I am moving from teaching kindergarten to fourth grade this year. My K students loved me and I loved them! I am not prepared to teach such “big” kids. However, your letter reminds me that they are still that…kids. They are 9 and are entering a new school. Some come from loving homes, some come from broken homes. It’s my job as a teacher to show each and every one of them love and support because that may be the only time they get it throughout the day!

Kylene, what a wonderful post. I have long believed that a child’s experience in first and second grade is of paramount importance. It is here that they can develop a love of learning or learn to dislike it because of a negative experience. I have an 11th and 8th grader now. My oldest didn’t have such a great experience early on and still doesn’t like school. My youngest had a much more positive experience and enjoys learning. While some of it is their personality, a large part I attribute to those early years. I commend all teachers for the job they do and wish them a successful school year.

I have two daughters, one in grade 12 the other in grade 3. My eldest had 1 or 2 great teachers, my youngest has yet to experience it.

I am waiting for the day I can feel the same.

Posted this for our staff as another year starts. Thanks for the reminder :)

Plan to share this on our Twitter feed. I hope you’ll consider applying for one of our grants. (www.fundforteachers.org/apply.php) We sent several Fellows to Maine where you are now!

Great article on how teachers teach more than school subjects, Great teachers teach life. Our son was hit by a car in the second grade and sustained life threatning injuries that kept him in the hospital, 100 miles from home for about three weeks. His teacher, Dr. Susan Morrison, made the trip to the hospital just to read to him and make him feel like he was still part of the class. Matt will graduate from high school this year and I guarantee there will be a special seat for Dr. Morrison at his graduation.

What a wonderful gift you have given in sharing such a wonderful story!! It made me think back so many years ago when I dropped off my daughter for her first day of school – I felt much like you did. Now her children, my grandchildren are entering kindergarten and first grade and this story made me feel so good! Thank you so much for sharing!!! This is one of the best “feel good” stories I have read in a while! God Bless You!

Reading this article my mind and heart went back to the day I took my daughter and all my sons to their first day of school. Those emotions I felt were so well expressed by this writing. Thank you for a very heartwarming story that brought back memories of long ago. Very well written and I must admit I am a little teary eyed.

Darn those ninjas with those onions….

I totally loved this and completely understand. There’s a point that was forgotten – at least in my case. I have an autistic son who is now in typical classrooms with a para for his tougher subjects only. The teachers I have encountered have not only encouraged and helped my son to grow, they have given me many suggestions and ideas on how to continue that growth at home – in academics, social skills, and behavioral skills. I have yet to encounter a teacher that has not been a team player. I will be forever grateful for all those players on my team (along with the para’s, ot’s, speech, and other therapists on his team). There just isn’t enough to show them how much they mean to me as a special needs mom. With all the horror stories out there in the special needs community, as a whole I believe there are more gems than junk.

Thank you for this wonderful article. I admit, the title gave me pause, as I am so weary of reading all the teacher-bashing that is so common these days. I was pleasantly surprised, and very touched.

I had my own “Ms. Miners,” and at 30 years old I still remember with love Mrs. Ruppert (kindergarten), Miss Koester (second grade) and many more throughout the years, all who took my hand and made me fall in love with them and with school and with learning.

I am a teacher myself, now, and as I prepare to begin a new school year your article is a wonderful, uplifting reminder that despite standards and common core and testing…we teach children, first and foremost. Thank you.
Spedventures´s last [type] ..Classroom Workday 1

This was such a great post!! I teach Kindergarten and just chuckle to myself when I see kids acting out how I read a book, or telling their parents that’s not the way Mrs. Gorbe does it. Matter of fact, I had a little guy named Ricky one year. He wore a white tank to school and would not put on a tshirt. Mom brought him in and asked me to tell him to put on the shirt. I said, “Ricky, put your shirt on.” He smiled and put it right on. Mom looked truly annoyed..LOL! I have my own kids and KNOW that what their teacher of the year says is always the truth, even if it’s different from what I’ve said!!!

Thank you. Just a reminder I why I love teaching so much!

Unfortunately, this is not the case in a lot of America’s schools. One of my daughters had great teachers and great experiences. My second daughter has had nothing but terrible teachers and terrible experiences. We are stuck as we cannot request teachers anymore in our district, when we bring up legitimate issues, the principle glosses over them, the teachers never get reprimanded, and the poor attitudes are reflected in how they react and interact with our kids. We can’t afford to send them to private schools or to home school, so we have to deal with the current situation within our district, which includes an attitude that we, as customers, don’t have any say in how things are run. 2nd and 3rd grades were terrible for her, really weighing on her self-esteem and confidence. The teachers were yellers, punitive, and labelling of kids, creating a very negative environment within the classroom. At least 5 other families complained about the situation, with no response. It is difficult from the parent perspective to feel so disempowered to help make positive change for all kids when we devalued as customers and advocates. I hate to bring down the sentiment, but not all families are having positive experiences in elementary school, where almost everyday should be a good day. Just my opinion.

THANK YOU!! Beautiful tribute!

I loved Mrs. Rasmussen. I practiced sooo hard to say her name just right. I told her when I grew up, I was going to teach Kindergarten – just like her. I adored Mrs. Wright, Mrs. Post, Miss Winn (I still remember when she got stitches from opening a lobster claw), and Mrs. Beck. Mrs. Beck even came to my wedding. Well, Mrs. Ras, I am a Pre-K teacher. I have been for 16 years and I love it just as much as I did 38 years ago when I walked in your room.

Thank you for writing this. I was a first grade teacher for 5 years and this makes me miss it tremendously! However, I have moved on to, what I consider, a much more important job of raising my new little girl. I do miss this time of year though and the excitement the little ones had coming into first grade. Thank you for reminding me of what it was like at the beginning of the year and the impact we have as teachers.

Well said! Here’s to Sister Marcella, my beloved 1st grade teacher and to my many teacher friends – you are all so important!!!

That was beautiful & brought tears to my eyes!! My 6 year old son started Kindergarten last year in a public school & he hated it. It was a struggle to get him out of the car & many days we sat in the office until he would agree to go to class because it was disruptive to the other students to watch him scream & cry & have this deathgrip on my leg begging me not to leave him. It broke my heart every day!! As a result, he became somewhat of a bully & did not learn much…As a single parent, I made the decision to send him to a private school. He is repeating Kindergarten this year & he loves going to school!!! He loves his Kindergarten teacher Mrs. O’Day!!! I thank God that I switched schools & now he is having a positive experience & is enjoying learning. It takes a special person to be a teacher & I hope they all read your article to understand that they do impact the lives of children. Thank you for sharing!!

So appreciated this article! I had a first grade teacher that was her first year teaching and she was also so wonderful! I Remeber going by her lunch table every day through the rest of my elementary school career and giving her a hug at lunchtime. I grew into highschool and began to date her son – I still so wanted her to love me and accept me! While her son and i were dating her husband passed away from cancer. She taught me so many things about relationships and friends and family at the age of 6 and 16!! The way she handled death and the way she accepted me into her classroom and family was so very admirable. I didn’t marry her son – but there is still a “forever” presence she had in my life and I am so very fortunate to have had a Ms. Miner in my Mrs. Fletcher! Thanks for the beautiful article.

I have looked at this topic from both sides. I am a mom of two adult sons and taught first grade for 34 years. Being a mom is the hardest job you’ll ever love, but being a first grade teacher (or kindergarten teacher) probably ranks second. My sons’ best years and subjects throughout their school years were when the teacher was well-loved and respected. I was always thankful for those individuals, because it was typically a two-way street! I know that I was “Ms. Miner” for many, but not everybody. While, I did try to make everyone my favorite, and was most often successful, I know that not everyone responded to me in that same way.
One of the best rewards of a long career in a small town has been keeping in touch with many former students into their college years and beyond.
This article was well-done, honest, and likely enlightening for many parents experiencing similar feelings at this challenging time of life.

Thanks for the good cry on my first week of school. I also remember my first grade teacher Mrs. Harold who had such a lasting impact on my life that I went back to see her in Tucson when I decided to go to the University of Arizona since moving to Maryland.

I walked into Steele Elementary which, when I was young looked so large, looked so small to me now and asked for her class. When I entered her room and greeted her she turned and said “Jesse McGee, I never thought I would see you again!” After 20 years she picked me out without me having introduced myself. We talked for about an hour. She remembered my mother, my brother and that I had a younger sister who was not yet in school before we moved to Maryland.

I didn’t become a teacher after college, I wanted to make “good” money. But 7 years ago I was offered the opportunity to switch careers and that conversation washed over me like a wave. She died last year and her daughter sent me an email, as Mrs. Harold and I had been corresponding since I became a teacher. Her daughter said that apparently Mrs. Harold had been talking to her family a lot about this kid she had back in 1978 who had become a teacher and how she was so proud of her students that gave back.

I will never be able to properly repay Mrs. Harold for the gift that she gave me, but I believe I can do her memory proud by trying always to make a possitive impact on children in my job today.

Thanks for the essay,

Jesse McGee
Network Operations Teacher
Thomas Edison High School of Technology
Silver Spring, MD

Kylene, I am smiling through my tears. What a beautiful piece, and so very true. After 26 years of teaching first graders, I retired last year. Through exhaustion, changing curriculum, rising demands… there was always love to sustain: I loved the children, loved what I did each day, loved watching them learn and grow, and, let’s face it – loved watching the look of love reflected back in their eyes. As a teacher of the little ones, I can’t imagine another career choice with the rewards that teaching gave to me.
Thank you for this beautiful tribute. With your permission, I would love to put a link on my teaching blog. (Yep, can’t ever completely give it up, even in retirement – it’s in the blood, as they say!) I think your post would be a wonderful encouragement to all of the teachers who read it!

This was a lovely read and tribute… I just wanted to add my thoughts in response…

For any teachers out there who may be reading all these responses to this article – at 28 years old, I don’t remember my first grade teacher. Or my kindergarten teacher. Or even my second grade teacher. No slight against them, mind you! I know I enjoyed our classes, and enjoyed learning in those early years. But as the author of this article said – no matter the age of the student, there’s always that potential of connection.

So for me, I remember my 8th grade English and History teacher, who had us read the Diary of Anne Frank, and then connected the story between her two subjects of teaching, so we started connected literature and history, along with the life lessons that both can provide for us. And then, later in the year, went on to play an old record (yes, record!) of Bill Cosby’s comedy, perhaps just to teach us about humor and irony….!

And I remember my 7th grade science teacher, who taught us all kinds of 7th grade science, but also told us to stand firm on whatever convictions or beliefs we had. That we should be open and search for the truth ourselves, but at the same time, not just believe anything anyone told us.

And most of all, my 11th grade English teacher, who would let me stay in her room during lunch, and would ask me to “fight off the philistines’ while she stepped out. She developed in me a love for literature that – in a tribute to moms out there -was first instilled in me during those pre-school years when Mom tugged us along to the public library and let us pick out as many books as we were allowed to check out, and then read them with us each afternoon.

Teachers are some of the best gifts we can be given in life – and I won’t even touch on the way certain professors in University also impacted my life’s journey and love for learning.

Thanks for this article and for the memories it stirred up. It’s important for us to reflect on the people who have touched our lives in some way.

I so loved this letter. It has been a half a century since I walked into my first grade classroom. I also don’t remember her name but I do remember I loved school every year all through 12th grade and college and even grad school. I suppose that had something to do with that nameless first grade teacher who made me want to come to school and made me want to continue to 2nd and 3rd and 4th and so on and so on. Next week I send off my first born into the classroom for him to begin his teaching experience. I will show him this letter and speak to him about the importance he can make in one life which makes everything all right in the world.

What a beautiful story. Making a child love school and love learning and making it so wonderful that they can’t wait to get there in the morning should always be the goal of the teacher. As a first grade teacher I hope I have created that environment and made a difference by providing the love of learning. It can take you to fabulous places! Thanks for sharing.

Priceless! My daughter just started first grade and she absolutely loved her kindergarten teacher! A special thank you to Mrs. Q who encouraged my daughter and the rest of her class to love school and everything it stands for! Mrs. Q is the perfect recipe for a kindergarden teacher! As a high school teacher, an even bigger thank you to Mrs. Q who helped me to grow as a parent of a kindergarten daughter! :)

As a high school teacher myself, this reminds me and encourages me to stay focussed on the child!
Encourage our children to grow and be the best they can be. When they fall, as educators it is our job to build them back up! After all, they are only children…..they need to be taught how to learn from their mistakes!

Thanks for sharing such a wonderful story.

Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts and feelings with all the parents, students, and teachers who are currently reading this. I have such great memories of my elementary school years. If I could, I would like to thank each and every one of them for making me feel special. As a teacher, I often wonder if my students will remember me. Did I make an impact? Did I make a difference? Did I make that child feels special? Are the parents happy with the progress their child made?

I smile as I read this. Yes. That is the answer I received after reading your letter. Thank you for answering my questions!

I hope my children loved their teachers like that and I hope I made some good differences in some of my students love of learning and of school through the years. Even though I can’t recall all their names now I often think of my classes and remember sweet moments and things that happened and wish I had written them down. What memories Teachers, keep a journal. Time pasts so quickly.

I loved first grade, and my teacher, Miss Moss, so much that on the day AFTER the last day of school she allowed me to come in and help her clean out her classroom. (My father was a teacher at the same school, so I went to work with him.) It still makes me happy to think about that. I wonder if she knew that I would feel this way nearly 50 years later.

Teachers can make such an incredible difference in the life of a child–both positive or negative. How wonderful that your daughter started off with one that made such a positive difference.

Wow.

[...] Facebook page. This is why we do what we do, even those of us who teach 12th graders. Here’s the link. When my first born headed off to first grade, 21 years ago, she held my hand as we walked down the [...]

This post just touched my heart as a parent and as a teacher. I was a multiage K-2 paraprofessional teacher. I loved all of my students. From the time they walked into my classroom in the mornings and until they left at the end of each day, they were my kids and I watched over them with as much love, dedication, understanding and protection as I did for my own sons. They are my future. What I put into them, I would, in the future, be rewarded by seeing good citizens who shares my world with values, morals, understanding of others and they would give back to their community their very best. That was my goal and dreams for them and their futures. A few weeks ago, I recieved an invitation in the mail to a baby shower for one of my former kindergadner students. I had seen her and her family through the years off and on for birthday parties, etc. but it had been years since I had seen her since her and her family had moved away. I had the privilidge of going to her baby shower and seeing just how she had turned out and how well she was doing after all of these years. She is going to be an awesome Mother. I’d like to think that all those years ago, I put a seed in her heart as to how to be a loving parent with all of the things that my mother taught me, that I taught my sons, and that I taught to my students by example. It was with great pride and joy that day as I watched her open her gifts and talk excitedly about her plans for the baby and her baby’s future. When I hugged her and left, I knew with great certainty, that she would be giving back through this child. I have to admit, there was a skip to my step as I walked to my car after the shower. I was busting with pride. I wish I could see all of my students from over the years and see how well they turned out. By now, they are scattered all over the world forging their own paths in life. I pray that I was a positive roll model for them and that all is well with their lives. God Bless Each And Everyone Of Them.

Oh, how fortunate Meredith was! After working once a week in my first child’s kindergarten classroom, I went back to work, just so I could afford private school. This was 1971 in the best school district in a suburb of Sacramento. Our son did have a good teacher there in the second grade, and then we moved to Seattle. One year in public school in the fourth grade convinced me that my children were too important for public school. They both attended a private school through 12th grade even though it kept us almost broke for 13 years. In private school we found teachers paid much less than in the public system who were ALL truly dedicated to their students. It wasn’t just a job for ANY of them. Our children had to put themselves through college, and both did so, one through grad school. They both are very succesful employees and parents, and we are so glad we chose the best we could possibly give them.

Beautiful!! Just what I needed to remind me why this career means so much to me. I love sparking the interest of my students, even though teenagers are more resistant than most :)

Thanks again!

I have taught elem PE for 33 years. Everyday I get so much more from my kids than I can really give.
Even better I was able to bring my children to school and teach them PE among other things and watch them up close as they grew in those early years. My kids were not important enough to go to private school but received a world class education from the public schools they attended. My daughter earned a National Merit Scholarship and graduated law school from William & Mary.

As a long time public school educator who worked with HUNDREDS of like-minded professionals, I find the statement “my children were too important for public school” incredibly offensive. Way to paint the dedicated, hard-working majority with the same brush as the shortcomings of the few! I think you missed the point…

Thank you for your gentle reminder of why I love to teach.

Wow…I had to catch my breath and grab as much bravado as possible so I did not let loose a tear! I remember my son’s first grade teacher, Mrs. Best; she was awesome! She stole my little boy Michael’s heart just like Ms. Miner did your little girl’s heart! I secretly hated her and loved her at the same time. My Michael just maried the girl of his dreams a week ago yesterday. At the wedding reception in the course of conversation, while Michael was beaming in pure adoration at her, she jokingly told me that he was hers now, not mine. My heart broke just a little bit, almost like after that first week of school 15 years prior. Again, I had to pull all the bravado I could not to let one tear escape! Well, all this bravado has finally faded! The tears are flowing freely now, as I type this on my phone. My little boy, my Michael, is in the Navy, a Nuclear Technician aboard the sub USS Charlotte, based out of Pearl Harbor, Hawaii. Now his heart belongs to his new wife, and it really hit me after reading your story. It all started so long ago, when his 1st grade teacher, Mrs. Best, stole his heart. Thank you for your story.

I recall Meredith at this age and even younger when she’d accompany you to professional meetings. How fortunate she was to have such an outstanding first grade year. Our three were not so fortunate to a Ms Miner. But two of the three have become Ms Miners to today’s Kylenes and Merediths.

I cried when I read this as a mom and as as teacher. My son had the most amazing kindergarten teacher and was incredibly lucky to have her again in second grade. He was very clever this year and asked her to be his confirmation sponsor. He told me that this way she will always be a part of our family. I hope all of us remember this story as we open our classrooms to our new students. I hope we teach and love them like we want someone else to teach and love ours.

This touched me as I stuggle each year to give up my children to teachers..whom I call people that think they know my children better than I do. It is rare in these days to find great teachers like this….but a blessing when we do…Thanks so much for posting…
bernadette bellanger

would u please email this to me at : bbbellanger2011@hotmail.com

Thanks so much!

Bernadette Bellanger

Thanks so much for the reminder of why we teach. If you don’t love children you shouldn’t be a teacher.
My husband works with very troubled teens in an education program & would tell you that those who are the hardest to teach need to feel this love and care the most. They may not be so fortunate to have someone at home who offers that, you as their teacher may be the only one in their lives who gives them love and support, so love the ones who are easy, but spend some extra effort and find a way to love the ones who are hard too. They probably need it far more. Treat ALL of them with respect, regardless if they are 5 or 15, no one wants to be talked down to.

This is what I needed to read. I wasn’t as excited as I have been in my previous years returning to the classroom but I am now! I am ready to make a difference in the lives of my students and once again each child will make a difference in mine! Happy school year everyone…

And that is why I teach….and why I’ve taught for 37 years. The joy of seeing my students grow to love learning…of “watching the light bulb go on”….of having a direct & lasting impact on the path of each of their lives…I can’t think of any other way I would have wanted to live my life!

Tear…Tear…as I sent my first born off to kindergarten this past Monday. I too hope she loves her teacher and obtains memories for life.

This was lovely!!!

As a mother and former teacher, I love the insight and wisdom in your post.

I met my daughter’s third grade teacher today, and sent a follow up note with a link to share this with her…I can already tell she is a Ms. Miner. :)

Thank you!

[...] When my first born headed off to first grade, 21 years ago, she held my hand as we walked down the hallway of Will Rogers Elementary School in the Houston Independent School District. We walked into Ms. Miner’s room and Meredith’s steps grew more hesitant. This wasn’t the University of Houston Child Care Center, the place she had gone for years while I was a doctoral student at UH. This place looked different – bigger, more official. There were big-kid desks pushed together in clusters. And though there were centers, they were not the dress-up center or the cooking center or nap center or water play center of the Child Care Center. More… [...]

I am a parent,volunteer, substitute-teacher, licensed-classroom-teacher;licensed administrator, community college adjunct instructor.

I have taught at all levels in the Pre-K-Community College level. I see students of all ages who fear their first day of school. A classroom that is inviting and a teacher who enjoys and loves their choosen profession makes the differents in the learning of their students. Everyone in that is assoicated with a child is responsible for the child’s education and growth into a productive law abiding citizen. Every school in America and the world can be exceptional when staffed with Professional Educators that work together for the benefit of the final product a well rounded civil minded highly educated group of students no matter what their ages. Educators are trusted with the most treasured gift that a parent/guardian can trust them with their child(ren). Granted there are good and bad parents/guardians just as there are educators. It takes a community to raise a child up right. Everyone needs to work together. There is to much ugliness in our society and it is time to turn to a brighter future for America and that is through the upbringing of the students. Blessings to all parents, learners, and educators across America and the globe.

[...] An open letter to America’s Teachers [...]

That was beautiful…made me cry.

Thank you for your post. I taught elementary school for 23 years and middle school for 12. I have been retired for 5 years now and I have taken to recently say that I escaped from teaching just in time because of all the political stress now associated with the profession. Your post brought back that place in my heart where teaching always was and had recently scarred over..now, at least, I can smile in memory of the many joys it brought me.

Beautifully said – and an important reminder for all of us who are educators.

I taught K and 1st grade for almost seven years and was always filled with joy when parents told me their children would say “My teacher said…”. That is until my own little girl did the same with her Pre-K and kindergarten teachers. I could not STAND those women and loved them SO much for taking care of my baby.

This was absolutely beautiful. I’ve spent the past couple weeks getting my classroom ready for my 23 new firsties and reading this just reaffirmed my mission. Thank you!

Love this, thanks for posting.

Thank you. As I finished the week with 125 middle schoolers, I wondered if I made a difference. This reminded me of what I don’t see. Thank you-

I was the oldest in my 2nd grade class, towering over the other children, chubby, terribly shy and without any self esteem. I had started school in 1st grade, skipping Kindergarten completely because I read on a 4th grade level and was already writing in cursive. I don’t remember much of my two 1st grade teachers. With all my accomplishments, I had to repeat the first grade. I was mostly self taught with help from my Dad. At the end of first grade the principal met with my mother while Dad was at work. He told her he wanted to skip me to 3rd grade because he feared I would be bored as I was so ahead of my classmate. But he did not know one thing; my mother hid mental problems very well and as a very crafty person was able to convince him to actually hold me back in first grade another year as I was “immature.” I had never cried and begged to stay home as she claimed; school was a wonderful escape I loved to enter each morning. I did not do any of the things she told him with me sitting there listening and I still remember how sad I felt when he believed it. I was not that little girl. I felt I was much older than my age and did house work,cooked and mainly took care of myself when my Dad was at work. When he was home he was mother and father to me. I got through that second 1st grade but at a cost. I was more shy than ever, had no self esteem and feared showing what I knew and how easily learning came to me. Then I walked into 2nd grade and saw her. Mrs. Carole. Third year teaching, blonde, young, beautiful and almost at once recognized me as a child who needed a mothers love desparately. She was a teacher who hugged her children, sat with each one almsot every day. Laughed at antics rather than get upset because she knew that sometimes kids just had to be silly for a moment. She ran with us at recess, forgave the paint on her new white blouse,and gave each of us a gift at Christmas that she had obviously put a lot of thought and love into. I still have mine, a copy of “Anne Frank’s diary”. Not the usual gift for a 2nd grader but I was by then reading at a high school level. She was mainly teaching me the subject I had not been exposed to – math, science, history. I had a slightly different set of homework from the other kids; things that made me wonder what I would next learn. By the end of the year I not only loved her I longed to be her child. When I learned she would not return the next year because she was having her first child, I wanted to scream, “Take me home with you!” The one and only time I spoke of her to my mother was to ask mother if she would roll my long blonde hair so it would be curly for school pictures and because Mrs. Carol said it would look so pretty that way. During the rolling I was slapped for moving, my hair pulled,and was tortured by mother’s attempt to make me feel guilty for “loving anyone but your mother.” I felt no guilt, I didn’t feel like I had a mother. Mrs. Carol showed me how to have courage in the face of odds I could not change, to have patience and know it would end someday, and later as a teenager I would remember all she told me of self respect and self love and I did not accept the invitations to get into trouble nor believe the boys who said if I loved I would show it. Mrs. Carol and a few other wonderful female role models taught me to be a wife, mother, and a strong, independent woman who could freely give and receive love. Mrs. Carol instilled in me a love of learning so deep, I have carried it with me all my life. I am 62 now, retired from a career in the aerospace industry, have traveled the world, raised four step children (one a teacher), and am now enjoying grandchildren with a wonderful husband. None of this would have happened if I had not been blessed with this remarkable teacher at just the right time. I last saw her when I was about 16, in a grocery store with my mother. I ran up to her and she remembered me. We hugged and she asked abour my grades and I could tell she was proud I was on the honor roll. She asked what I would do after high school and I told her I wanted to go to medical school. Her eyes lit up but before she could say anything my mother informed us both there would be no help from my parents because college was just a place a girl went to find a husband and was a waste of money. All the families support would be given to an older brother, my mother’s chosen child. He is a doctor today. I was 33 when I finally received my BA. 53 when I went back for a 2nd degree. So teachers can make a difference because the last words Mrs. Carol said to me before she left my life forever was “I know that you will be whatever you want to be and can go to college on your own.” As it turned out, I decided medicine wasn’t for me after working as an orderly in a hospital. But even before I finally went to college, I held positions of responsibility that most women of my young age did not at that time. Mrs. Carol’s lessons in courage, learning, love, respect, and so much more has been the greatest gifts of my life. I told my story because I wanted other to know of her and to realize that just one year in a student’s school career can lay the foundation for their entire life.

What a touching story, Anne. There are many times I feel like I’m not making much of a difference in my students’ lives beyond the academics but your story is a great reminder that sometimes we have an affect way beyond the books.

Very touching! Teachers are worth their weight in gold for all the wonderful things they do.

Thank you for the wonderful reminder of how precious we are in the lives of children. I have 20 Pre-K babies to love and shape this year. I truly believe this year in Pre-K can make or break their entire future. To all the moms please know we, as teachers, don’t try to take your place and we are sorry for all the times you have to be corrected to do it our way. Looking forward to another blessed year. Thank you parents for entrusting teachers with your most precious gift, your child.

I teared up reading this. As a middle school teacher sometimes it is hard to remember how huge of an impact you can have on each student in either direction. Thank you for reminding me!

Thank you so very much for such an eloquently written letter. I taught for 33 year –mostly 1st and 2nd graders. They were my loves, my children and I tried to teach them as if they truly belonged to me. My own children were lucky to have amazing teachers throughout the years who molded their minds and helped them become the terrific adults they are today. I remain friends with many of the parents of students and the students themselves. I cling to the compliments from past years that made a sometimes difficult job worth while. One of my favorites was a mother who wrote me that her daughter had said she wished she could have 2 moms–her own and me. Thank you for this post.

Oh, this is lovely. Thank you so much. I have been a piano teacher for years and thankfully and gratefully I was able to understand these things when I started teaching. I had a lovely piano teacher and I will never forget her.. Since, I have tried to emulate the same kind of love and understanding of the difference in each child and their ability… Please, teachers, both public, private and musical….. in order to teach, you must also love…There are many problems in our world today and sometimes in families.. So, be aware, that you might be the nicest person a child meets all day.

After my first week back at school, I took my coffee to the sunroom and began looking through a box of old photos. Embedded with them were so many letters over the last 25 or so years from my middle school students who had, at the time of writing the letters, finished high school and college, many now in the working world. Some thanked me for what they learned in my English class, but all shared their appreciation for helping in more personal ways. I had forgotten those incidents, in the process of taking care of twenty-five years of incidents inbetween, I suppose. I’m so glad I kept those cards and notes! All these years later–this is year 41 in the classroom–my heart is full but not too full for a few more middle school students who need a hand to make it through the day.

This article was wonderful!! I loved my 2nd grade teacher. She CARED for us and what was going on in our lives. She let me bring in my baby sister for show and tell because I was soooo excited to be a big sister! Mrs. Urinak was awesome and inspired me to teach. This is my third year teaching high school music and I love my kids and I have enjoyed watching them grow throughout the years!!

I loved my sixth grade teacher, Lucile B. Hardaway! I kept up with her for years and years until her death. I am 61 years old now and I still speak fondly of her.
On the otherhand, I also tell sad stories of my third grade teacher who just didn’t like me or my mother!
Such influence teachers have – good or bad – whether they try or not.
~Mad(elyn) in Alabama

My first-grade teachers name occurs frequently in my conversations after 75 years! Must have made a lasting impression

I like this story. When my son was well into his first year at a nearby Montessori school, he began to call me “Mrs. Chakrabarty” and then laughed and said he called her “Mom” sometimes by mistake. I found it surprisingly delightful that the two most important women in his life were so influential that they sometimes blurred in his young mind. It reassured me how secure he was in his child’s world. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

I am a mom and a teacher and this made me well up with tears. Thanks for publishing…I needed this!

It is so refreshing to read a post by a parent about the positive impact a teacher had on her child’s life. Reading this made my day. Thanks!

I’m a mom and a teacher too. I have chills and teary eyes – thank you!
Jemi Fraser´s last [type] ..Look!

Wow, this brought tears to my eyes. I just retired from teaching 34 years this past June. I’ve felt a little lost these past couple of days, since school started. But then I think back to the impact that my teachers had on me and why I became a teacher. I guess the “teacher” in me will always be there! God love all those men and women that continue to teach!

Very touching… A parent knows the impact of teacher much more than we ever get to know

so simple and so true. the impressions do not stop in elementary school. thank you for sharing.
-high school special education teacher

This touched me in so many ways: as an elementary teacher for many years, as a mom raising her babies while working through her doctoral program and now as a professor of education and a mom sending her oldest daughter to first grade. I will pass this along to my future teachers to get them excited about the impact they can make on so many children and to all the moms who will have the same tears that I will have in a few weeks- may we remember that although there is some sadness in the tears, these are actually tears of joy!

Love this post. Unfortunately my son had the opposite teacher. I hated her for not being the teacher above. A teacher can make or break a child. I am a teacher as well and I work very hard to never make a child feel the way my son felt. Thank you to all those that actually help a child become wonderful adults!!

I think my first grade experience was the flip side of your story. I remember my first grade teacher fifty two years later, but not with joy and happiness. I was miserable. I hated school from the beginning through high school. It wasn’t until I went back to college as an adult that I truly enjoyed the classroom. Teachers often forget how much they impact the lives of their students.

Wow. This made me get a lump in my throat and tears in my eyes. I have a disabled son, Zain Semones, who has Hunter Syndrome, or MPS II. It broke my heart to pieces to leave him on his first day of pre-school, as we had received his diagnosis less than one month before that day. We tried for four years to get him to conform to the “ways” of structured schooling, and found that it just wasn’t possible, so we elected to do home-school. I was “on the fence” as far as wanting a “Ms. Miner” for Zain. I needed that for Zain in order to feel comfortable, and mostly for him to feel comfortable. However, sharing him after the diagnosis was heartbreaking for me. His pre-school teacher was the opposite of Ms. Miner, making his pre-school year very upsetting for me, with lots of confrontation, then his kindergarten year, we got our Ms. Miner. She is indeed the reason Zain has fond memories of the public schooling he did have, as it did take a short while into his kintergarten year for him to see that this school thing can be enjoyable after having a not so pleasant year before. My daughter, Star Semones, who is now 8, whole heartedly loves school. I surely welcomed the school experience, and her bonding with the teachers, as Zain didn’t have much of that. As a parent, I guess we don’t appreciate the “Ms. Miner’s” as much as we should, until we don’t have them when they are needed the most.

Amy Kemp
Pulaski, VA

I just now added a post to this story, but didn’t select to be notified by e-mail of new posts, so I’m re-submitting for that reason. Thanks

Amy Kemp

I was ready to put on my teacher super hero cape and come to the defense of teachers everywhere. Then I decided to read the whole post not just jump to the comments.

It was lovely. Thank you. It reminds us all what an impact we can have.

What a beautiful tribute to teachers! May I please share this with my colleagues?

This is aweome! It not only illustrates how important teachers are in a child’s life, it also educates parents about the special bond between a teacher and his/her students. Sometimes parents, especially with a first child going off to school, struggle with this new and very important person in their child’s life and can even feel like their teacher is more important than they are because the child talks about the teacher alot and may compare the parent actions to their teacher’s.

Thank you for the reminder that we really can make a difference a year at a time one student at a time. You made a difference for me in a graduate course at U of H a long time ago. I can’t remember ever being in a class I enjoyed more. I have 3 children of my own who love school and have had some amazing teachers. I am now teaching Middle Schoolers who have learning difficulties and doing Educational Therapy. I love my job! I also love the teachers that I’ve met along the way who have been amazing examples to me. Thank you for being one of them.

I am sad to say that my oldest did not get a 1st grade teacher, who was kind to her students. When she discovered my daughter was left-handed, she tried to force her to learn with the right hand. My strong-willed child stayed strong and continued being a leftie.

2 weeks before the end of the school year, I made a surprise visit to the classroom and caught the teacher angrily throwing my daughter’s work into the trash can, chastising her for smeared work. I saw my daughter literally shut down and refuse to do any more classwork for the teacher. I privately confronted the teacher and said I didn’t want to ever hear from my daughter that there was further retaliation. Because my daughter’s scores were excellent, the teacher couldn’t get away with flunking her. I was so glad to hear from the principal, that the teacher didn’t come back the next year.

Two years later my other child was in 1st grade, so I hoped things would be different. The teacher was friendly and seemed to be good at teaching, but she had one problem–wanting children to wait till recess to use the rest room. First graders’ small bladders just can’t handle that. Sure enough, I received a call requesting that I bring a change of clothing for my child. Again, I had to stand up for my child and tell the teacher to never allow another “most embarrassing moment” to ever occur again.

I have been teaching for 26 years, and tonight I went to the wedding of one of my former kindergarten and second grade students (had the joy of teaching her twice!) This article hit home with me, because it’s all about building a relationship with our students!

Wow! Thank you…for this beautiful letter. I,too, am a teacher who loved and adored her teachers growing up. I have just started my 25th year..I taught 1st grade for 20 years, had the opportunity, to loop up with 2of my classes and transferred to Kindergarten last year. I have been Blessed with children and families who have shared their lives, and love with me and allowed me the opportunity to educate their child(ren). I have taught, learned, laughed, cried, and grown into a better person because I am a teacher. The best compliments and reassurance that I have received over the years is having so many of my 1st or 2nd graders come back and ask to student teach or do their HS child development time with me…I have had so manybeautiful Ms. Minor memories.. my 1st year…Nick’s mom came in crying at conference time.. I was worried.. She handed me a little box through her tears and said ..here..This is for you.I opened it up and there inside this beautiful ring box was Nick’s mom’s 25 cent ring that he had bought for his mom last Christmas and decided that I NEEDED to have it because he loved me so much..I started crying too.another quick memory..was again at conference time, a mom walked in who I had not met yet..she said.. I have waiting to see what “god”looked like.. I said…ahh.. I beg your pArdon…well,whatever YOU say in our house is gospel..she told she waNted to hate me ..but could not because her daughter hated kindergarten and they had prayed to get a happy loving 1st grade teacher..and through her tears and giggles, we had realized her prayers were answered..it was then and there..with so many more Ms. Minor moments that..yes,teachers..you,me, we do make a difference in children’s lives! Let’s all make it a positive one this year..See, I am now on the other side.. needing and hoping that you will be positive for our beautiful children ..ages 12 and 7..who have been Blessed almost every year with a Ms. Minor.. Thank YOU!!! Meredith Wallace Claborn

Kylene, what an absolutely wonderful piece! Just as so many of our children will be meeting their teachers for the first time. I saw this post from friends who are teachers and I’m so happy to share that they are the “Ms. Miner’s” for the children in their classrooms. Again, this was so beautifully said. Thank you.
Jean

Thank you for reminding us teachers of this just as school is beginning. I AM a teacher because of my 2nd grade teacher Ms. Latimer. I truly love each of my kinder students and speak to others as if they are my own. When delivering my 3rd child, the Dr asked how many children I had and I answered with out hesitation 24 :) He thought I was crazy but only 2 were my biological children.

I love this story! I felt the exact same way about my own first grade teacher, and I grew up to be a first grade teacher (striving to be exactly like her). Thanks so much for sharing and reminding us what teaching is all about.
Hilarie´s last [type] ..Baby Butts and TexMex

Thank you for sharing your story. I have been teaching for 13 years, but it was when my own boys started school 5 years ago that I really understood the emotions that parents feel. Thank you again.

Cromer, Williams, Cross, Thompson, Irby-Hamm, Peloquin, Clayton, Wolfe, Bush, Allen, Davis, Harry, Pruitt……..the names of my teachers flood over me as I read this article and these precious posts by parents and teachers alike. I am lucky to say that I had many “Ms. Miner’s” over the years but I must say that one stands out….Mrs. Richey. She was a young Spanish teacher, newly married, had just done her student-teaching, she was beautiful, and all the boys were in loooooove!
She brought more enthusiasm to teaching than I think I ever remembered! This stuff mattered. She then would proceed to teach you WHY it mattered! In the midst of it all, I learned I mattered. In the fall of my senior year, I participated in a speech contest and placed second in state. In this contest, a scholarship awaited the winner, but there was no prize for second. I felt that all of my time had been wasted and it left a very bitter taste in my mouth. In history class that spring, our history teacher had us do a project where we recorded a speech at a local radio station which would then be judged nationally. It was the first (and only) time I ever refused to do an assignment. Later, as I was explaining what was wrong to Ms. Richey, I broke down. I needed someone to listen and she was there. The next day I found a letter in my folder from Ms. Richey talking about a disappointing experience during her own HS graduation. Then she went on to explain how this assignment seems big now, but won’t effect much in your future. She told me to believe in myself and that bigger and better things were waiting down the road.
I went on to major in and teach HS Spanish for 3 years and then took a different opportunity to teach in a state prison system. I teach life skills: thinking, decision-making, pro-social behavior, and employment skills. With Mrs. Richey’s enthusiasm, I teach them to believe in themselves and that bigger and better things are waiting down the road. Through her words, wisdom, and empathy for one sad HS student, hundreds of students are touched yearly with those same words. I still keep that letter of written so many years ago and pull it out of my wallet to read it when I need encouragement.
So thank you Mrs. Richey, you literally shaped a life by taking time to sit down and write three short paragraphs for a student who desperately needed it. As you said, I don’t teach Spanish, I teach students! To teach is to touch a life forever, and I can see your impact on my life in so many ways. So, wherever you are, from the bottom of my heart, thank you.

As a Mom of three and a preschool teacher, this post made me cry like many others have shared they did. I can vividly recall the teachers that made me feel special, the teachers that have made my daughters feel special (my youngest is a sophomore in high school now), and how I have felt about the preschoolers and their families I have cared for for the last 5 years as a teacher and 4 years before that as a preschool aide. Such beautiful words!! None of us want to be replaced by a teacher and stare in awe as a teacher has the magical ability to get children to do things that are almost impossible as a parent, but am so grateful first for those teachers and then that I have the distinct honor, privilege, and humble opportunity to be one of “those” teachers. ;) Thanks so much for so eloquently sharing what many of us have felt. Ms. Barbara from For the Children

Oh, this post left me with tears streaming down my face – as a teacher and especially as a parent of an almost-kindergartener who I’m having a really hard time letting go of. Thank you for sharing your perspective – I needed to hear it!

Wow. Just wow. Your title hooked me in, and your ending made me cry. Others have already thanked you and complimented you, relayed their parenting stories or their teaching stories. As a teacher and parent, I wholeheartedly agree with and share the feelings of these people. So I thank you for your wonderfully honest words, and will pass them on to my friends and colleagues.
EntertheGreenhouse´s last [type] ..Ninth birthday party @ 4Cats

Thank you so much! I am a teacher. I barely get paid enough to make ends meet. As we get slapped around more and more often over the years (by administration, the school board, politics, parents, and the media), I often wonder why I stay in the profession. When I look into the eyes of a child that loves me I quickly remember. It’s that and stories / kind words like yours that keep us going. Thank you from the bottom of my heart!

Thank you, Kylene, for this beautifully written post. I shared it with my staff as a way to welcome them back to school. I am so inspired by your work and feel honored that I could learn from you this summer in Boothbay.

I have been involved in assessing children for years and for various reasons. When I want to know how they will do in school, their answer to my question, “Does your teacher like you?” is always the most reliable predictor.

Thanks for your touching post.

Your story is so beautiful and a wonderful reminder of how much we do mean to our students and their families, I’m a preschool teacher and often forget to see it from the parents handing over their precious cargo. Thanks for sharing. :) Clair in Ireland.

Dear Kylene,
My name is Maria Caulfield,and I was Meredith’s preschool teacher at UHCCC, and I am from Costa Rica. I was delighted to find and read your article that one of my fellow teachers posted on facebook. I told my husband, I know Meredith and Kylene. Also, I remember Meridith’s cousin, Reed. I had so much fun with my “older three’s class. I need to get my old school pictures from Houston and look at my old students. I can’t believe they are adults now. I live in Kansas now and I am a school counselor. Please tell Meridith and Reed that I still remember them. My time at UHCCC was wonderful. I treasure those teaching years in my heart!

This is a great story! I am a teacher and have been teaching for 6 years and we always think about the parents who don’t like us but not sureas the reason why or the impact we can have on their children! this story is also exciting bc I went to Will Rogers Elementary School and Ms. Miner was also my first grade teacher and that it was also her first year of teaching so I was in your daughters class! I still to this day rememberher and her sugar free candy she would give!

Thank you for writing and posting this. Last week my doors were opened to my 1st 6th grade class. I’ve been a teacher for a while, but is was my first time in 6th grade,and I still strive for them to love me like I’m a back up mom! Some of them still need the hugs of reassurance that someone understands them and is in their corner! I felt very good about my week, and then I got a note from a child on and BIP and my heart melted. She loved me and said I’m her favorite teacher ever, that no one ever took the time to get to know her and help her! Yipppeeee I love it when I touch their souls! Thank you, God, for giving me the power to live through your design!

To Kyleen and all the other people who posted:
Yes, I too cried at the original letter posted but I have cried at all your responses to that letter. We don’t get to share experiences enough that make our profession worthwhile because it sounds like we are bragging. BUT we need to stand taller and prouder and share those because many of us have dedicated our lives to the students we teach. We do treat them sometimes better than our own children. Don’t we often send more time with those students trusting others to love our own children as much as we love our classroom children? I wish I could say my own children had a Ms. Minor…but both my boys always told me I was their favorite teacher and wished they had a teacher like me. That makes me sad!!!! I have many relationships with students and have attended showers, weddings, and school events for them. Some students while I was still teaching would come by and see me…that brought a lot of joy to my life. Facebook has been a great way to stay connected to many of them and their lives. My first granddaughter is 6 months old and I am already worrying about her. I know there are lots of Ms. Minors out there and I pray she gets at least one of them. I have retired after 31 years of loving every single child I ever taught. I am not going to say that was always easy, but I found the positive and used that as the entry to that love. I miss those arms hugging my neck but I know that I used my God given talents to teach and love children and am thankful that I made a difference in their lives. God bless each and everyone of you that continue to use your talents because these children are our future.

Thank you for this inspiring piece. I have to admit, from the title I was a reluctant reader. There’s so much negativity and pressures, I was scared to read about one more thing I needed to avoid/start doing. Thanks again for writing such a wonderful article, I am sharing, hoping all my colleagues will read also.

Beautiful and articulate! As I prepare for my new 6th graders, this narrative will continue to resonate for me. Thanks Kylene.

As I prepare for my 14th year teaching this was just the article I needed. Thanks so much! I spent 10 wonderful years as a Kindergarten teacher and was blessed to have so many parents share their wonderful children with me. Now as a district Library Media Specialsit I get to interact with every kid from PreK-Senior at some point during the year. Although my interaction is different than it used to be, I strive to be just one student’s “favorite” teacher every year. If I can be that teacher for one kid, I have made a difference.
Thanks again for the inspiration!

I also would like to add a comment about teachers aides. Sometimes if the teacher is not so loving as Ms. Miner, the aides can fill that spot. I love working with kids and have made some very special relationships by being the aide. I can be fun and like to get down and meet them at their level. That is why I am working toward getting my degree.

I still remember all the teachers that have effected me so… Mrs Roebuck, Mrs Bishop, Mrs Best, Mr Bundy, Mr Cuddy, Mrs Peterson, Ms Meyers, Mr Ferris… Teachers have such an impact that I sometimes don’t even know if they truly understand. I only hope that my sons will have teachers that impact them the way that mine did me. I loved school, and even after two Master’s degrees later, would love to go back. I was shown how wonderful knowledge and learning could be, and that was the best gift!

I am a former elementary and high school teacher of special needs students. I so remember the half bottles of perfume “snitched” from a mother’s bureau, to be given to me as a gift. Or the parent that was so upset to learn her daugher had been stealing my colored pens and pencils to use at home to play school. I never knew that I had lost the pens and pencils…….as I had so many! I never rebuked the child and just thought it was so funny that they wanted to show their love for me.
I recall my own first grade teacher, Mrs. Loveless. What a name, but she was so opposite. Once during naptime, the teacher next door was in charge of us while our teacher had a short break. I sneaked out of the classroom and took two other children along, to play on the sidewalk that had iced over. We were having a great time “ice skating” until the other teacher caught us. I was placed up against the locker as punishment. When my own teacher returned, I just knew I was going to be in such big trouble. But she kindly came up to me, whispered in my ear to return to my seat in my classroom. Not one other punishmet, not even a reprimand came from her mouth. I was so relieved that she put herself in my place and knew I was just being seven years old and finding a bit of fun on a icy sidewalk. That was probably the only time I ever misbehaved in school. I so thank Mrs. Loveless for not calling my parent or punishing me further. I am sure that the two teachers had a good chuckle abou tit……..I was just too young to realize that it wasn’t a terrible thing………to iceskate on an icy sidewalk.
I also loved my next two teachers, Miss Pasty Sweeny and Miss Linda Stroope. Miss Stroope taught me everything about bees, as her father was a bee keeper. I never forgot any of that! I often stayed after school to help her in the classroom before I walked home. With Miss Sweeny, I remember her giving out parts for a class play. I watched as she called up various students and gave them out parts. I waited, but I wasn’t called. I was an excellent reader and did not understand. I tearfully went up to her desk and asked if there was a part for me. She gave me the best part! I was the sheriff!! I was the hero of the entire play. The play was about tooth decay!! So funny now! But I was the sheriff who fought tooth decay and won!! I could have cared less that it was a boy’s part. I was the sheriff!! I will never ever forget that this teacher saved the best part for me.

Dear Kylene,
I teared up at this beautiful letter. I had the unfortunate experience to have a 1st Grade teacher, that for whatever reason, I felt did not like me. She sent home notes to my parents that were negative, most of which my Mom kept and I now keep as a reminder of what not to do in the classroom. In spite of hating 1st Grade, I became a teacher and strive everyday to love my students and make them feel special. It’s hard to remember how much teachers mean to their students, it’s also hard to feel like you make a difference when you have almost 30 Kindergarteners all day. Your letter reminded me that no matter how many students I have or how overwhelmed I feel, these little people need me to be the best teacher I can be.
Thank you for reminding me :)
Mrs. P

I loved this. The teachers in my life have made such a difference. Thank you.

Loved this. Loved it.

I love this story!It does make us as parents more comfortable knowing that our kids are happy at school!And now that my son is starting his 3rd year at college it is so much easier knowing that he is happy at Eau Claire!He does love it there!We would like to Thank all the teachers that made his years of school a great experience!You all had a big part of the young man that he has turned into!:)

What a beautiful story! I am a school secretary and feel honored to work with so many wonderful teachers. My special child had the privilege of being cared for and educated by many kind, imaginative and fun school personnel. I think there’s a message here for every person who works in a school. Thanks for the reminder! May we share this at our school?

[...] and the privileged position a child’s first teacher has.  We read Kylene Beers blog ‘Why I Hated Merediths First Grade Teacher…’ and it brought a tear to the eye and a sense of pride to be part of a profession [...]

Amen.

Wonderful story, I can only hope and pray when our Layla begins school she’ll have a Ms. Miner as well!

I taught first grade for 30 yrs. and retired from teaching after 34 yrs. I live in the same small town where I taught. And now I substitute teach there. I love seeing my former students grow and become the people they are becoming. There were times that could be difficult as a first grade teacher, or any grade level teacher, but for me watching the excitement of learning to read and discovering books was the best part. My saying always was (and still is), “Readers are Leaders”. I wouldn’t have traded my 30 yrs. with those students for anything else. God blessed me with an amazing career!

Wonderful letter. Didn’t you used to teach at Holub Middle School in Alief? My son, Chris, who attended Holub, found this and put it out on his FB. I’m sure he also shared it with the campuses he mentors.

I’m 84 and I still remember my kindergarden teacher with love. Miss Griggs was her name. She let me sit under her desk and dig though a basket of colored scrap papers for cutting and pasting. I did become a life-long artist, and thanks again to Miss Griggs for recognizing my interests.

So beautiful! Brought tears to my eyes! :) On the first day of school, I always give my kids’ teachers a “thank-you-in-advance” note, thanking them for all of the things they are going to teach, share, and create with my boys — some of which I’ll never even know… Mostly, because, it wasn’t until I was on the other side of the teacher’s desk, that I realized just how much trust all of my students’ parents had placed in me over the years! <3

I just wanted to say, as a teacher I have been greatly moved and inspired by my students over the years. There are many students who will always have a special place in my heart.

I read this I prayed my daughter who is attending 1st grade this year enjoys it as much as she has for preschool and kindergarten. Its amazingly true how we are brave for them yet crumble to leave and come years end are so proud of all they accomplished knowing if it wasn’t for the bond with the teacher they would not be where they are. I’m so blessed my daughter had amazing preschool teacher and kindergarten …..thank you tor all that you do!

I loved my kindergarden teacher. She gave me the love of school and learning. I am a first grade teacher—love my job and the children I teach! Loved reading this story!

My elder son had the misfortune of having a thoroughly burnt-out kindergarten teacher. She was extremely rigid and harsh – so much so, that he forever hated school. It was such a waste of a smart, creatively gifted child because to this day he never wants to take on educational expansion of any kind. Thanks a lot, Mrs. Cowan of Hamilton Ontario Canada!!!!!

[...] different – bigger, more official. There were big-kid desks pushed together in clusters. source Previous Topic: « Chris Evans angers neighbours as vintage rally vrooms into village [...]

I love this. It brought tears to my eyes. I hope I touched some of my students the way Ms. Miner did with Meredith. :)

Lovely sentiments that all mommies share. I taught at the Elementary level for many years before moving up to middle-secondary. One of the best lessons of teaching grade 1 is I have never forgotten, even now when I have to look up to most of my learners, is that they are still someone’s baby. You are so right.
Lisa Read´s last [type] ..Transition

My son is just starting preschool this fall (a whopping 1.5 hours twice per week) and this blog almost brought tears to my eyes, and I am not the emotional type. Love the sentiment and I can only hope he will find such a fabulous teacher. Thanks!

What a beautiful posts. Our daughter-in-law started today 8/28 with her very first Kindergarten class. She has been long term subbing for the last 1.5 years and finally has her own classroom. She has worked so hard. I have complete faith in her that she will be a teacher like the one in this story. So proud of her.

love this!! my youngest had a very bad kindergarten teacher. she hated to go to school and always had a stomach ache. she is now in 3rd grade and it has been a struggle to try and get her to like/love school again but it is slowly happening. it all comes down to the teacher!!

I read with opposite feelings…I never wanted to leave my Mom! However she opted the best for me to stay! As my whole life through I look back and attributed my first grade teacher the most sensitive one. Funny at 61 I look at still pleasing my homemaking teacher in high school if she was still teaching me how to cook.hahahaThrough the lives of teachers it has formed my Godly character. I salute the time they have given to me!

As a retired elementary teacher, mother of two teachers and grandmother of five, BINGO! You’ve said it all!!

Hello! I am a third grade teacher and have a first grade daughter at school with me this year. I, like you, have both shoes to fill. I’ve read your blog post a few times, and it always brings tears to my eyes. I love the time I spend with my kids…I enjoy getting to know them, forming bonds with them, and rejoicing in their successes. I cry every last day of the year when I have to say goodbye, passing them on to another grade level. Even today, one of my former babies came to the office and was greeted by his teacher this year…it broke my heart! Like my other students, I adored him, worked hard with him, and was so proud of his progress and his love for learning. I know that his current teacher will love him too (she is a friend of mine), but I still feel an attachment and a sense of responsibility for his progress and learning. It’s hard to let go… My own daughter adored her kindergarten teacher, and is thankfully in the room next door this year. I heard all about her over the summer. She adores her first grade teacher as well. I am thankful for that. I am blessed enough to work in a school where we all share a sense of responsibility for OUR children. I know in my school, teachers like your daughter’s first grade teacher are the norm…I really hope that is the case across the board.

I am so thankful that I stumbled onto this profession after a few other avenues were visited. I love everyday I get to spend with my kids, and I can’t imagine another job being more rewarding. I truly hope that I am the Ms. Miner to many of my students and their parents.

Love this! It spoke to me as both a mother and a teacher. I remember my youngest daughter’s first day of Kindergarten. Her teacher was young, enthusiastic, and pregnant. My daughter was so enthralled with the whole experience that she turned around to me and my husband and said, “If you get lonely or bored without me, you can play with my toys! I’ll let you.” Sniff, sniff…

Kylene, I am used to being filled with tears when I read your books and listen to your presentations because you talk about the real things in teaching–the students. Yesterday as our newsppaers carried their stories of the first day, I recalled how I stood with my daughter waiting for her bus that first day. How she bubbled and how I cried. I also know how you make me laugh when you talk about the same subject, kids.This year there will be no bell for me thatr first day because the state has determined that I have used up my years. I miss it alraedy.

I don’t have any children and I got a little choked up when I read this. So beautiful and so true, the effect an amazing teacher has on us all. When one of my teachers told me how proud she was of me (I was in elementary school), it hit me to the core and I’m forever grateful for the amazing teachers I had while growing up.
JulieD´s last [type] ..Linguine and Clam Sauce Recipe from Jenna’s Book, White Jacket Required

THANK YOU! I just loved reading this…it reminded me why I became a teacher in the first place, and inspired me as I start another school year!

We all need a Ms. Miner in our lives, and if we have never had one, we teachers hope to become one in the lives of our students. Thank you for posting this, and for helping us see ourselves through the eyes of the children in our classrooms.

This is a perfect post to share with my granddaughter who is beginning her student teaching in a few days. I am a retired teacher and saw myself is many of the activities and thoughts.

Thank you for sharing this post. I believe it has come to me from a devoted, retired, teacher friend who has sent her treasured daughter into “the field” and soon, I will be watching my granddaughter develop and use her skills with those her life touches.

Again, thank you and thank you Nancy,

I’m not in the teaching field, but I have always felt that teaching is one of the most important careers there is. Along with Nursing, you both touch so many lives. You instill many, many things in children that you can not even imagine. Love you all. We were raised in the 50′s, when teachers were more like drill sargeants, but they still loved each and every one of us. We learned a tremendous amount from them and still remember it to this day. I love watching the teacher awards once a year. Thanks to all teachers.

I’ve taught first grade my whole teaching career. Thank you for reminding me on my 35th first day of school how important we are in the eyes of a child.

Wonderful posting, just had to share on fb with all of my teacher colleagues. Thanks for the inspiration.

You brought tears to my eyes.
Thank you for the wonderful tribute to our teachers and for using Ms. Miner, my daughter, as an example.
Ms. Miner (MaryAnne Miner Malicki) was heart broken this summer when a new superintendent at her school failed to renew her contract after 13 or more years at the current school for reasons unknown. She was loved and adored by most all parents in the manner that you described in your article.
She is now pondering on continuing in the teaching profession or opening a new door.
A loving Father

I am also a first grade teacher, the best grade to teach! I have also heard from my parents that what I say in class is often repeated at home. I find that both scary and humbling. I do think my students’ families know how much I love their children. I am truly blessed to work with them.

Kylene,
Thank you for your beautiful article. A friend had forwarded it in hopes that I might be the Ms. Miner you spoke about…and I am! Your words spoke to my heart as I ponder what the Lord has in store for me as I venture onto a new journey in life. I would love to see you and my sweet Meredith. Please keep in touch.

Much love and gratitude,
Ms. Miner
(MaryAnne Malicki)

I loved this ode to a teacher! I am in my 10th year of teaching Pre-K and I love it!! My favorite teacher was in 3rd grade – Mrs. Jackson – and I still see her at church, at club meeting, and visits at her home!!! She encouraged my love of books and reading – she taught me manners when I politely had to listen to another classmate’s boring “show & tell” discourse when I all I wanted to do was read a book; I pray that I make an impact on my students as she has done for 51 years of my 59-year-old life!!!!

Beautiful, sensitive and oh, so very real! Thank you for sharing the feelings most parents not only feel, but hide as to not influence their children going forward in that BIG world of school.

My daughter had that kind of teacher named Mrs. Little. Kindergarten was amazing and influenced my daughter and myself as well. I made regular monthly visits at school her 1st year…it’s why eventually I got my teaching degree. I spent my final months in college in the room of that same kindergarten teacher and thanked her for she had done to energizing my daughter’s and my life to go forward to touch the lives of new children each and every year!

Thank you so much for dredging up memories of students post high school returning to thank me for helping them a) learn how to learn via their interactive notebook, which they had kept; b) opening up the world to them through reading articles outside the classroom and responding in writing to those; and c) see how science is relevant to all aspects of their lives. We do often hear about “self-contained” elementary teachers making a difference, but ALL teachers do build relationships with kiddos and do make an impact, whether positive or negative. Thanks for the reminder!

What a beautiful tribute to teachers!!!
For all of you out there who still aren’t sure, yes, TEACHERS do make a difference!!

I scrolled through the comments looking for Ms. Miner to answer and she did! Ms. Miner – stay in the profession if you can – you have made a difference and will continue to make a difference. I teach 5th graders and the bottom line is they have to know you care about them each and every day – and you showed them you do! I’m sure the reason why you weren’t rehired is because they could hire a new teacher for less money – but what they don’t realize is that you would be worth the higher salary to the parents and students you teach.
Kylene – thanks for sharing this beautiful story with all of us parents and teachers.

Beautiful. Just beautiful! I loved my first grade teacher, Mrs. Read. So much so that I voted her to be among the “Best Teachers in America” many years later. She wrote me a hand-written letter thanking me for doing that – turns out she got nominated by me in her last year of teaching (unbeknownst to me).
Lindsay | The Daily Awe´s last [type] ..How To Get The Universe to Show You A Sign

for those of you with children who have had negative experiences with teachers, YOU are in control. start gathering evidence of the shoddy teaching or negativity shown your child. if you hear that other parents are experiencing similar things, UNITE! go together to talk to the principal and if he brushes you aside, go HIGHER! there is always a chain of command–use it! if your child has behavioral issues, dn’t allow the child to be repeatedly punished–demand that the child be thoroughly evaluated and let the school providew a fair and equal education based on the child’s needs. no child should have to experience men teachers or “have a bad year.”

What a great tribute to the greatest profession in the world! In my 24th year of teaching, I have been energized by the knowledge of the impact we have on young people’s lives. During the last four years I had the opportunity to instruct at-risk students at the local learning center in our town. After building relationships with these young adults, I inquired about the reasons why these young people were turned off on school, each student could remember the moment that they were labeled as a trouble youth. In each one of these students, I witnessed a positive change in the way that they looked at school, their teachers, their classmates, and most of all THEMSELVES, once they figured out that their teacher was “in their corner.” Unbelievable! Now, this year, I am back in the regular classroom, I focus daily on what I have done to make their lives better and their outlook positive. Two of the greatest educators that I have had the honor of knowing and working with had this attitude of being positive up to the day that each retired. They are my role models. They were “EDUCATORS OF EDUCATORS!” Thank you, Mrs. Terri Williams and Mrs. Connie Erickson. I admire you. I respect you. I cherish what you have taught me.

Thank you for inspiring me this morning. As Penny Kittle said, you are our teacher. I was in love with my first grade teacher too. Just last week while having dinner at Mom’s house, Mrs. Madigan again came up in conversation. It wasn’t until my son fell in love with his own teachers (kindergarten and fifth grade) that I understood the bittersweet joy of handing him over to a great teacher. This post captures it perfectly. Thank you.
Lee Ann Spillane´s last [type] ..Talking Teachers

[...] Great Teacher, what every child needs. The best way to reduce learning disabilities and dyslexia is with a great [...]

Thank you for this beautiful post. I am also a parent who watched my children go through this process. As a teacher, this year is full of change, cut backs, and frustration before we even open our doors. I know that the district is doing what they can yet it is difficult to watch as the students have less and less time with the teacher as classroom size increases to outlandish numbers, more testing, and restraints imposed on what/how we teach. You made my heart fill with excitement again to anticipate seeing those faces again. Thank you!

That was beautiful. Thank you for reminding me why I became a teacher. Your appreciation of what we do fills my heart. God Bless!

Always A Lesson

That’s a beautiful story about Meredith; however it does not always go that way for all children.

My son’s 1st grade experience was a nightmare. Every day I came to pick him up I would hear something negative. I began to realize that it was not a behavior issue. My son was a round peg in a square hole. The traditional learning methods were not working for him and the school actually took away his love for learning for awhile.

I realized that I had to step up to the plate and homeschool him. Now I know that he has Aspergers and dysgraphia, a problem with handwriting.

So this Labor Day I am preparing to start school tomorrow. This will be our fifth year. I would not trade it for anything. Not all children fit into the traditional school mode and some fall through the cracks and have horrible experiences.

While other mothers are saying goodbye to their children, I have the great privilege of teaching him. Maybe I have less free time, but that’s okay, because I know that I am called to this. It is my responsibility has a mother.

I am extremely thankful that God was preparing me for this role in my life. It’s not the easiest thing to do but it is the best decision I ever made for our family and my child.
Dana´s last [type] ..How to Start Business Without Money–Your Fourth Step to Achieving Your Dreams!

I am a long time ago graduate of U of H childcare center and now a third grade teacher. I so loved your article. I could still relate to being Meredith and Mrs. M. Your story is what helps teachers stay motivated to keep making a difference and impacting lives. Plus we totally love it when kids copy our good parts because I’m pretty sure my own offspring don’t. I hope my oldest gets a Mrs. M in kinder next year! Thanks again!

What a wonderful blog post. As a teacher, I hope that parents and our children understand how much their children have an effect on us. I still have a picture on my fridge of my first Pre K classroom and often think fondly of so many children I have thought over the year. It is such a joy and blessing that parents partner with us to teach their children and allow us to care for their children for 180+ days. This definitely bought a smile to my face.

Thank you for this timely reminder! My school year hasn’t started yet as I am a “Guest Teacher.” But this message is for me as well.

Connie Verbeck

I am in tears as I read this. It brings me back to when I went to kindergarten, Mrs. Smith was her name and she was my everything. When I became a Mom and my girls went off to school, I was so hoping that they would have Mrs. Smith also, but no luck. I would see her in her classroom as I would be in the school and she still had that smile I remember as a little girl in kindergarten. I have gone on to be an educator because of her. My dream was to be a kindergarten teacher. I am an owner of a child care center of 177 children a day. I have the best of both worlds, as I get to see them grow into young boys and girls. While reading this with tears in my eyes, I am going to print this out and give to all my staff and post for parents. I am also going to contact Mrs. Smith as she is still alive and only living a few towns over to see what a difference she has made in my life.

Ms. Miner is my little sister, always will be. The one I teased and pulled her pony tail. She is a special teacher and still is. Thank you for acknowledging her effort these many years later.

When you take my child’s hand, you hold my heart.

As a literacy coach for the past ten years I can say that without a doubt it doesn’t matter how smart a teacher is or how many years she has under her belt, the best teachers I’ve witnessed are the ones that make each child feel special. My husband and I have 70 years of teaching under our belts together and we look back and hope we’ve made a difference in helping children both young and old to feel like we truly cared about them. I can still remember the first day of kindergarten in 1952 and Mrs. Royal smiling at me while she sang off-key at the piano. Every teacher needs to know how important they are in shaping a child’s school experience.

I am currently studying to become a high school teacher and this made my day! Thank you so much for putting into words what I have struggled to express: why I want to be a teacher. People wonder about the long hours and the small pay and all the stress and why I am willingly putting myself in that, but this is exactly why!

I loved your story and would like to pin it on Pinterest, but there is no image to pin. Would you consider adding one? I am guessing a lot of us would love to pin this.

Thank you for your words. I truly love what I do and the love I get back is worth more than the pay. This is my 2nd year as a 1st grade teacher out of 12 years of teaching. I was always in the upper grades 4th- 6th. But I have to say I am so loving it. As a parent I know exactly how you felt. My own daughters a 3rd grader and a kinder have their teachers on a pedestal.

Thank you, this made me cry. We are in the midst of major industrial action in Melbourne over pay, conditions, performance pay, cuts to education…the list goes on – it is a hard time to be a teacher. I teach prep and am in my second year of teaching having returned to study in my late 30s with a family of my own. My prep parents often tell me that they get thoroughly tired (in a joking way) of hearing ‘Mrs Nicholls says…’. I love what I do and even though I am working for half the money and twice the hours of my old job, I wouldn’t change it for the world.

This made me cry. As a teacher I hope to affect kids positively like this. As a mom putting her only baby girl into daycare this week I also have the irrational fear of being replaced in my girls heart. It’s a tightrope walk of emotion !

[...] her blog post, Why I Hated Meredith’s First Grade Teacher: An Open Letter to America’s Teachers, Kyleen Beers [...]

Oh, how I wish I had a Ms. Miner! Reminds me of my 3rd grade teacher. She was young, fun, pretty and I wanted nothing more than for her to like me. You see, she had favorites and joked around with certain students and I so desperately wanted to be in her “clique”. Looking back, it makes me sad beacuse she was really the first introduction I had to “cliques” and feeling left out. She was the teacher everyone wanted to love, but I have a feeling she made more kids feel left out than love. She is still teaching, some 20 years later. I hope she has changed.

I shared a link to this beautiful piece on my blog today; thank you for showcasing this wonderful teacher. God bless all the Mrs. Miners out there! Thank you for loving our children and wrapping them in your blankets of care.

http://corneroncharacter.blogspot.com/2012/09/a-climate-of-careacter.html
Barbara´s last [type] ..A Climate of CAREacter

Beautiful!!

I shed a few tears reading this. My daughter starts her first day as a world history teacher this week, which happened to be my major in college. I’m grateful for teachers and also moms who pass on their passions!

[...] & union contracts the past week, Kylene Beers wrote a lovely teacher tribute about her daughter’s first-grade teacher, remembered from 21 years ago. Every one of us should write one of these & send it to our local [...]

I loved every minute of raising my 2 Daughters,LEIGH and ERIN.They were exited and nervous about school,but soon grew comfortable.Making lunches,talking over the days activities,volunteering..I miss it more than them! It is difficult ,at first, to discover they admire someone OTHERthan their own Mother,but it soon becomes ok.We truly hope that when we send our little TREASURES to school,that the caretakers will open their minds,their worlds,offer kindness and understanding,to watch out for them,and to appreciate them..being a mom has taught me much about love and about life

[...] by Kylene Beers’ recent blog tribute to her daughter’s first grade teacher (read it. now.), I decided to write my own tribute to a teacher who had a significant positive [...]

[...] read a blog not too long ago, I echo the sentiments of Kylene Beers.  So with that, I will end by saying, [...]

This post made me cry. I expected to hate it, as I expected you to rail on some teacher who didn’t make the grade. But instead I found love and tears.
I have an education degree also, and am often torn between how much my four children have loved certain teachers and how much that means they love me less.
Two of mine are done with traditional school, at ages 19 and 20 and two are almost done, at ages 12 and 16.
Last year was a very hard year for our family and my son’s fifth grade teacher pulled us through, without even realizing it. Here’s the post I wrote for her.
Not a first grade teacher, but loved all the same.

http://justonefoot.blogspot.com/2012/05/year-we-survived.html

Yours is a beautiful post that I found while searching for something totally unrelated. :)
Judy

Touching story. I’m not fond of my sons teacher and found this by mistake. So far we have drawn the short straw on 3 teachers. Alot of negativity and failure to notify of problems or progress until its too late. Im glad to see that all kids and parents didnt have to go through this.

You should take part in a contest for one of the greatest blogs on the net.
I will recommend this site!
spike heeled boots´s last [type] ..spike heeled boots

I remember you, Dr. Beers. My name is Chris Summers and I was the PTO president for awhile at WR and I had 5 kids who attended WR school. I don’t think you liked me very much at that time. We may not have agreed on some things but that was long ago.

But I don’t hold anything against you. My kids are all grown now and I have 13 grandchildren. My kids collectively went on to receive good educations, one son graduated 17th from the USNA. Others completed good educations at other schools. One of my daughters is a certified Somolier.

You never know what the future will bring.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays!

I hope you and your family are well and wish you the best. Do you remember me at all?

Great and nice post thank you.

I loved this. Isn’t being a teacher the greatest job in the wworld. I am so proud of the mail I get from my former students! I know my hubby felt the same way about his career as an educator. I miss him.
We were blessed!

に関しては、生産する研究を無視して、”本当に多くの理由のため、この問題が発生して横方向に多くを移動するために必要とするスポーツゲームのためにランニングシューズのペアを着用productsFNeverするために “科学技術の革新”とつながるその背後にある理由の一つは、あなたの靴はそれはクッション性を提供し、今日は最も引っ張りだこの一つとして浮上し、その広範なためにスポーツシューズで好ましい選択肢たshockTheナイキブランドを吸収する小さな気泡で構成されたクリーンアップを取得するために必要なことかもしれませんすべてのスポーツのための靴のデザインのラインはあなたの全体の足の跡を見ることができる場合は、平らなアーチを持っているこの決定はあなたの靴を形作る構造、後に上部のタイヤの空気圧を提供し、あなたの判断と快適さのレベルに基づいて行うために、すべてあなた次第です最後の靴の2つのベッドなので、靴の形をその最後のアッパー形状を正確に

[...] Several months back, maybe even longer, I stumbled upon an article that brought me to tears. The title intrigued me so the mother in me had to find out what was written on the other side of the link. And even though I’ve read it before, it still makes me a little emotional thinking about it. The article is titled, Why I Hated Meredith’s First Grade Teacher. [...]

Leave a response

Your response:

CommentLuv badge

Categories

Visit Us On TwitterVisit Us On FacebookCheck Our Feed